5. Wild Turkey 101 (Price: $25)
Whether considered the best or worst-kept secret in bourbon, Wild Turkey 101 continues to be a reliable favorite. Despite the growing popularity of new releases from its sibling brand Russell’s Reserve, Wild Turkey 101 stands firm. Its high bottling proof enhances signature flavors of vanilla, toffee, and baking spice, complemented by subtle vegetal undertones. This versatile bourbon is perfect for sipping neat, on the rocks, with a splash of soda, or in cocktails. Wild Turkey 101’s consistent quality and robust character make it a must-try for bourbon enthusiasts.
Rating: 87
4. Knob Creek 9-Year-Old Bourbon Whiskey (Price: $37)
Knob Creek 9-Year-Old Bourbon Whiskey is a top-rated choice for bourbon enthusiasts. This premium bourbon offers vibrant red fruit notes and delicate baking spices, diverging from the typical peanut and caramel flavors found in older Knob Creek bottles. With a robust 50% ABV, it delivers exceptional depth and complexity on the palate. Known for its outstanding value, Knob Creek 9-Year-Old Bourbon is perfect for those seeking a well-balanced and flavorful bourbon experience.
Rating: 89
3. Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon (Price: $35)
Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon is a top-rated choice among bourbon aficionados. This premium bourbon is crafted by blending four select bourbons, resulting in a unique and complex flavor profile. It offers rich, spicy flavors with notes of sweet oak, caramel, and mellow fruit, enhanced by hints of vanilla and baking spices. Its smooth, well-balanced palate and long, satisfying finish make it perfect for sipping neat or mixing in cocktails. Renowned for its consistent quality and expert craftsmanship, Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon is a must-try for those seeking a premium bourbon experience.
Rating: 89
2. Maker’s Mark 46 (Price: $42)
Maker’s Mark made waves in 2023 with its first-ever age-stated bourbon, becoming an instant hit among tasters. Due to high demand and resulting price increases, we recommend the dependable Maker’s Mark 46. This bourbon enhances the brand’s signature wheated profile, offering a consistently excellent experience. Ideal for bourbon enthusiasts, Maker’s Mark 46 is a top choice, balancing rich flavors and exceptional quality.
Rating: 92
1. New Riff Distilling Bottled In Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon (Price: $49)
New Riff’s Bottled In Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon stands out among craft bourbon brands, making significant strides with its experimental releases. This flagship bourbon is a must-try for enthusiasts, offering a perfect balance of flavors. It features enticing aromas of red and dark berries, complemented by tingling baking spices and a subtle hint of apricot puree. The result is a rich, well-balanced palate that showcases New Riff’s dedication to quality and innovation. Perfect for those seeking a consistently impressive bourbon experience.
Rating: 92
